I really don’t like to overgeneralize. I really don’t. But having been back during this time of year, three years in a row now, there are things that consistently bother me about the city I call my second home. It’s really difficult for me to reconcile a lot of social cultural differences in general and the things I’ll be talking about are enough to make it difficult for me to take the big step of living in Singapore and assimilating myself in the city for a good amount of time. I’ve had my fellow Singaporean friends confirm that these were all fair frustrations but of course, these are just based off of my own experiences so take it with a grain of salt and compare it with your own judgements. But let’s get started. Where does beautiful Singapore fall short?
Singaporeans are always late.
Singaporeans seem to have a different sense of time than North Americans. I’m often really shocked to hear that a 30-minute trip by train or car is “damn far” or “too long”. I live in Toronto, Canada and it’s very normal for people to travel one hour or more to get to work, meet up with a friend, get to the downtown core, etc. Topographically, Singapore’s a small country. I mean real small. For comparison, Toronto, a single city, is 630.2 km², while the whole country of Singapore is 719.1 km². Canada’s size? 9.985 million km². Canada’s the second largest country in the world by area, so I guess I might be comparing extremes here. Anyways, while we’re used to the trek, they are not and it will often be an excuse not to show.
If SGer’s are not complaining about the distance, they’re late. If I meet up with ten people, nine out of ten of them will be late. I’m not exaggerating. And I’m not just talking about ten, fifteen minutes. I’m talking about an hour+ here sometimes. I find that Singaporeans leave just enough time to do things, arrive to places and when meeting up with me, there isn’t any exception. They don’t seem to account for slow-downs and when they’re late it seems so much easier for them to blame it on circumstances that seem out of their control. I got held up a work. I didn’t know traffic would be like that. The MRT broke down. What bugs the hell out of me is when someone leaves once I’ve mentioned I’ve reached the destination at the intended time and that has happened to me on multiple occasions. Do I just have shitty friends? Regardless, I’ve stopped taking meeting schedules so seriously when I’m in Singapore. I think the Singaporean culture of being late comes from habit and mentality. Singapore as a city and Singaporeans pride themselves on efficiency (so kiasu) and they loathe wasted time and energy (so kanchiong) but it always seems to be at the other person’s expense, which leads me to my next point:
Singaporean service sucks.
Singaporeans seem value and prioritize efficiency at the cost of hospitality and it drives me absolutely insane. I was at Ya Kun Kaya Toast ordering breakfast with a friend. It was my first meal upon arriving, actually. “What do you want?” the cashier asks in Chinese, devoid of any sort of facial expression. My friend orders soft-boiled eggs, kaya toast and a Milo dinosaur for me, a set of distinctly Singaporean food items to set the vibe for my arrival. The cashier tells us the total. I held my money out almost right as she said it. Even though she was very aware that I was ready to pay, she did not acknowledge me and she went on to preoccupy herself with something else. She might have been shifting around plates on the counter, I’m not sure. But I stood there, hand out with money in my hand, waiting for her to collect it while she just watched me from her peripheral for an uncomfortably long time. She could have at least told me she’d take a moment. After she finally took my money and the transaction was done and over with, I made quite a fuss about it to my friend as we walked away and the impression I got from him was that I was being a little overbearing. “But it’s efficient”, he says.
A similar incident occurred at a Toast Box. The total came up to be $10.40. I gave her a fifty dollar bill. Just a second later, I informed the cashier I had 40 cents that I could give her. She made no gesture or acknowledgement that she had heard me say anything at all, not even giving me any sort of eye contact. She appeared to be rummaging for change for the initial amount I gave her so I said it again. Still no facial expression nor acknowledgement. But when she handed me back the change, I could see that she did in fact hear me as she accounted for the 40 cents that I hadn’t yet given her. I complained to my friend that the least she could do was say “OK” or nod at me. He responded by saying that he knew she heard it by her body language and that Singaporeans don’t have energy to waste on small things.
Small things? Efficiency should not be at the cost of service. I think I’ve been conditioned to expect a certain kind of service structure that North American establishments provide. Being greeted before being served, being told that someone would be a moment when they needed it, the culture of service with a smile, etc. I think I’ve been especially spoiled working as a restaurant evaluator in the past. I remember timing how long it took a server to refill my water or to note whether to not they greeted with eye contact and a smile within the first minute… Regardless, I’m entitled to have my own opinion and I think local service staff in Singapore are generally indifferent and rude. To be fair, I think my statement applies to very specific cases. Usually hotels, upscale dining, or basically anything that you would very obviously expect great service from, do pretty well. I’m mostly just complain about the service from casual and fast-food dining. In Singapore, it is common for you to see a 10% service charge on your bill and you are required to pay it regardless of whether or not you’ve received shitty service.
Singapore really prides itself on multiculturalism but it’s not true multiculturalism.
Singapore often prides itself as a multicultural nation and as a city that is often said to set an example of multiculturalism at work for the world. According to Wiki, as of 2017, “Singapore is a multiracial and multicultural country with ethnic Chinese (76.2% of the citizen population), indigenous Malays (15.0%), and ethnic Indians (7.4%) making up the majority of the population.” There are also major recognized racial groups like Eurasians and angmoh (Caucasian) ex-pats that are becoming increasingly common. Singapore furthermore has four national languages: English, Mandarin, Malay and Tamil. When you hear passenger announcements on the MRT or see pedestrian signs within the city, you will often hear and see all four languages being used. While Singapore is multicultural with a capital M, it isn’t truly multicultural in the way Toronto is. Singapore is very clique-y and it feels like there is a huge social gap between ethnic groups. You can definitely feel racial tensions and some sort of racially superiority complex going on when you’re there, with angmoh or perhaps the Chinese being on top and the migrant Malays being on the bottom. The kiasu mentality has made the typical Singaporean believe that blue-collar jobs are beneath them; to work in the service or construction industry is to be at the bottom of the rung, so menial labour jobs are often left to darker, migrant workers like Malays, Sri Lankens, Filipinos, Bangladeshis, etc. It’s shocking that these racial gaps exist within the younger generations. One thing that I noticed is that for a “multicultural” nation, there isn’t a lot of interracial dating going on between certain groups. While angmohs are on top of the dating chain, you will rarely see interracial dating between Chinese and Malays, although both are the largest ethnic groups. The Chinese will hang with the Chinese, the Malay with the Malays, the Indians with the Indians, and they all kind of stick to using their native tongue so it reinforces the division between them all.
Canada, like Singapore, prides itself on multiculturalism. According to StatsCan, one in every five people are foreign-born. Back home in Toronto, I can definitely feel a strong social intermingling of different ethnic groups and I think a strong reason for that is that we don’t have four national languages. Isn’t that ironic? The fact that everyone uses English, one common language to communicate, really promotes a sort of unity between everyone. And though we have existing stereotypes about ethinic groups and jobs that we giggle about (Indians in taxi cabs, Koreans in dry-cleaning shops, etc.), we have a fair distribution of people from different backgrounds doing every job. Could you imagine if it was only blacks doing construction menial labour?
I read an interesting article on the concept of multiculturalism here. It makes a really interesting point that using multiculturalism as a national identity is very “unbecoming of a self-professed global city”. If we think about it, multiculturalism should be a sort of baseline that every city should reach. It’s like professing that you’re LGBT-friendly — who shouldn’t be LGBT friendly?
Singaporeans are close-minded.
This one probably gets to me the most. It’s really hard for me not to be self-conscious when I’m in Singapore. I’m told that because of the tattoos and coloured hair, I’m automatically assumed to be a degenerate and possibly an ah lian (There isn’t a North American equivalent but a bimbo comes close enough). In other words, Singaporeans will automatically assume that I am uneducated, unsophisticated and ignorant all based on the way I choose to dress and present myself. Singaporeans are expected to dress, act and speak in a certain way and once you break that image, people don’t seem to know how to take it. My cousin once said to me looking at my tattoos: “Why so man?” Tattoos are strangely understood to be a very masculine thing.
Singaporeans seem to live in a sort of bubble. Society dictates how you should behave, how you should not behave, and there is a shared aversion for things that do not conform to the norm. From young, children are taught how to progress in life and everything is mapped out: study hard, get good grades, get into university, get a job, save CPF, get married, buy a HDB flat, have a family and you teach that same cycle to your children. Sure, this all sounds very normal being raised in an Asian household but there are key details that make things significantly different. So CPF, or Central Provident Fund, is the Singaporean government’s way of taking care of its citizens. It is a mandatory social security savings scheme, which takes a percentage of your monthly salary (37% if you’re under 35 for an idea) which goes into an account that can only be accessed when you’re 55. In other words, you’re forced into having a retirement savings plan. End of story. Sure, it’s almost like a non-screw-up program and it’s great for some people but the fact of the matter is, Singaporeans can’t even choose when to spend their money and, a scarier reality, how they want to live their lives. Because Singaporeans don’t have the luxury of choice, they can’t afford the risk of disrupting this seamingless failproof bluemap. CPF’s not the only thing that robs its citizens choice. Another good example is a limitation on owning property: You cannot purchase an HDB flat as Singaporean single (not married) until you are 35.
Factors like these really set limitations on one’s lifestyle. Growing up in the Western world, I feel like I have the luxury of choice. I can choose to save or spend my money, I can choose to buy property, but ultimately, I can choose how I want to live my life and pursue a lifestyle that works for me. As a result, I have a wider perspective for what I want for myself, not only for my living preferences but also in understanding myself as a person, allowing me to further learn and grow. If I had been born in Singapore, I think things would be much different. I wouldn’t be so open-minded, so transient, so free to express myself. I’d be instantly tied down, another cog in an insular society, where the only obvious option would be to conform.
Singaporean girlfriends are batshit crazy.
I’m not joking. This is a very serious point I have to make. I have to say, it’s really difficult making friends in Singapore because there will always be a batshit crazy girlfriend that will stir things up and cause some unnecessary drama. I have to have secret meet-ups with guy friends because they’ve been forbidden to hang out or speak to me. I have multiple crazy SG girlfriends stalking me while I’m in town or on social media in general. (Hi, Felicia). I have to play coy so I don’t set any alarms off that I’m a man-eating succubus from the West. Let me share some super short stories:
I watched a proposal video of a friend’s brother who lovingly said to his wife-to-be: “I’ll never to take another photo with another girl ever again”.
I was in a photo with six guy friends that we had taken during Halloween Horror Nights at Universal Studios. One of the guy’s girlfriends saw the picture and asked him, “Where are her friends? Why is she hanging out with you guys?”
I hung out with a guy who told me not message him about us hanging out because he wasn’t allowed to hang out with girls and his girlfriend read all his messages.
So yes, I have to say: Singaporean girlfriends are just insecure as fuck. I’m speaking generally, of course. 🙂
Alcohol is damn expensive.
My friend Toast pointed out that I missed this point so I’m adding this one after I’ve posted. One thing I love to do is seek out the best cocktail bars that a city has to offer but in Singapore, it’s a very, very expensive activity. Cocktails are on average $20-25 each and a beer’s around $15, unless you’re drinking in a hawker centre where it’ll be around $6.50 or so. Alcohol is heavily taxed and it makes drinking a luxury, I’d say. I had been a little more controlled this trip around, training for the Standard Chartered Marathon but I can’t say it’s been easy to go through a night without emptying out my wallet.
So, those are my main issues with a city I still very much love… and I’m actually back in Singapore on the 9th. Anyone want to hang out and not be late?